Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey vs Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer
Both made our Best Deep Fryers for Turkey shortlist, at #1 and #3. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL if you want the only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey. Choose the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer if you'd rather have 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch. Overall we rank the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Deep Fryers for Turkey list.
Winner overall: Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL vs Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 3 in Best Deep Fryers for Turkey | #3 of 3 in Best Deep Fryers for Turkey |
| Pick label | Top pick | Best overall |
| Brand | Masterbuilt | Cuisinart |
| Key features | Rated for turkeys up to approximately 18 to 20 pounds; 1650W heating element; Porcelain-coated inner pot and basket | 1-gallon removable stainless steel oil container; 1800W immersion heating element; 2.3-pound food capacity |
| Biggest strength | The only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey | 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch |
| Main trade-off | Single-purpose appliance that mostly sees use around the holidays | Single basket means sequential batches for very large amounts |
| Best for | turkey | french fries |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick · Top pick
Choose the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL if…
- The only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey
- Certified for indoor use removes the propane and tip-over risks of outdoor turkey fryers
- Porcelain-coated pot and basket clean up easier than bare metal after a full bird
Best for: turkey
Prefer the alternative? See the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer section.
#3 pick · Best overall
Choose the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer if…
- 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch
- 2.3-pound capacity fries a full family-size batch in fewer rounds
- Viewing window lets you watch color develop on the second fry without lifting the lid
Best for: french fries
Prefer the alternative? See the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL section.
Pros and cons of each
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL
Pros
- The only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey
- Certified for indoor use removes the propane and tip-over risks of outdoor turkey fryers
- Porcelain-coated pot and basket clean up easier than bare metal after a full bird
- Doubles as a steamer and boiler for other large-batch holiday cooking
Cons
- Single-purpose appliance that mostly sees use around the holidays
- Large size still needs dedicated storage space for the rest of the year
Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer
Pros
- 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch
- 2.3-pound capacity fries a full family-size batch in fewer rounds
- Viewing window lets you watch color develop on the second fry without lifting the lid
- Removable oil container makes it easy to strain and reuse oil between fry sessions
Cons
- Single basket means sequential batches for very large amounts
- Bulkier housing than a compact dual-well unit
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL vs Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer: common questions
Which is better, the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL or the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer?
Choose the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL if you want the only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey. Choose the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer if you'd rather have 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch. Overall we rank the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Deep Fryers for Turkey list.
What is the difference between the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL and the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer?
The Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL stands out because the only fryer on this list actually sized to submerge a whole turkey, while the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer stands out because 1800W element recovers fast between the first and second fry of a double-fry batch. The trade-offs differ too: the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL's main caveat is that single-purpose appliance that mostly sees use around the holidays, and the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer's is that single basket means sequential batches for very large amounts.
Is the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL worth it over the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer instead if single-purpose appliance that mostly sees use around the holidays is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer instead of the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL?
The Cuisinart CDF-200P1 Professional Deep Fryer suits french fries, while the Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL is best for turkey.