iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain vs InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower
Both made our Best Shower Curtains shortlist, at #1 and #2. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch if you want highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options. Choose the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch if you'd rather have lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed. Overall we rank the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Shower Curtains list.
Winner overall: iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch
iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch vs InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 10 in Best Shower Curtains | #2 of 10 in Best Shower Curtains |
| Pick label | Top pick | |
| Brand | iDesign | InterDesign |
| Key features | Woven polyester construction; Extra-long 72 x 84-inch sizing; Reinforced buttonholes | Clear PVC vinyl construction; Fully waterproof, single-layer use; 72 x 72-inch standard fit |
| Biggest strength | Highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options | Lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed |
| Main trade-off | Does not block water on its own, requires a separate PEVA or vinyl liner | New-vinyl odor is noticeable for the first several days out of the package |
| Best for | Most buyers | Most buyers |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick · Top pick
Choose the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch if…
- Highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options
- Extra-long 84-inch drop fits high rod mounts without leaving a gap above the tub
- Reinforced buttonholes hold up to years of daily hook friction better than unreinforced punched holes
Prefer the alternative? See the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch section.
#2 pick
Choose the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch if…
- Lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed
- Wipes clean in seconds and dries fast between showers
- Clear design lets light through, useful in a windowless or small bathroom
Prefer the alternative? See the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch section.
Pros and cons of each
iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch
Pros
- Highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options
- Extra-long 84-inch drop fits high rod mounts without leaving a gap above the tub
- Reinforced buttonholes hold up to years of daily hook friction better than unreinforced punched holes
- Drapes naturally and machine washes without cracking, unlike vinyl
Cons
- Does not block water on its own, requires a separate PEVA or vinyl liner
- Absorbs moisture and dries slower than any plastic curtain in this guide
- 84-inch length is oversized and pools on the floor for standard 8-foot ceiling installs
InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch
Pros
- Lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed
- Wipes clean in seconds and dries fast between showers
- Clear design lets light through, useful in a windowless or small bathroom
- 6,200+ ratings at 4.5 stars back consistent quality at this price point
Cons
- New-vinyl odor is noticeable for the first several days out of the package
- Sticks to skin and clings more during a hot shower than fabric or PEVA
- Cracks at fold lines and grommets sooner than a fabric curtain paired with a separate liner lasts
iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch vs InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch: common questions
Which is better, the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch or the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch?
Choose the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch if you want highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options. Choose the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch if you'd rather have lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed. Overall we rank the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Shower Curtains list.
What is the difference between the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch and the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch?
The iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch stands out because highest rating count in this guide (9,800+) at 4.6 stars, the strongest track record among fabric options, while the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch stands out because lowest-cost path to a single-purchase, fully waterproof setup, no separate liner needed. The trade-offs differ too: the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch's main caveat is that does not block water on its own, requires a separate PEVA or vinyl liner, and the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch's is that new-vinyl odor is noticeable for the first several days out of the package.
Is the iDesign Fabric Shower Curtain, Long 72-Inch by 84-Inch worth it over the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the InterDesign 26680 Clear Vinyl Shower Curtain 72 x 72 Inch instead if does not block water on its own, requires a separate PEVA or vinyl liner is a deal-breaker for you.