Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator vs COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel
Both made our Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky shortlist, at #1 and #3. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator if you want 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover. Choose the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator if you'd rather have 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step. Overall we rank the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky list.
Winner overall: Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator
Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator vs COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 4 in Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky | #3 of 4 in Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky |
| Pick label | ||
| Brand | Excalibur | COSORI |
| Key features | 9 stainless steel trays, 15 square feet of drying space; Adjustable thermostat, 105°F to 165°F; Parallex horizontal airflow | 10 stainless steel trays, 16.2 square feet of drying space; 1000W element with rear-mounted horizontal airflow; 95°F to 165°F in 1°F increments |
| Biggest strength | 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover | 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step |
| Main trade-off | 105°F floor is higher than the NESCO, COSORI, and Presto, less ideal for the most delicate herbs | Newer to the category than Excalibur or NESCO, with fewer years of long-term owner data |
| Best for | herbs | jerky |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick
Choose the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator if…
- 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover
- Horizontal airflow dries every tray at nearly the same rate for consistent batches
- Stainless steel trays clean up easily after resinous herbs like rosemary
Best for: herbs
Prefer the alternative? See the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator section.
#3 pick
Choose the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator if…
- 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step
- 10-tray capacity rivals the Excalibur at a lower typical price
- Rear-mounted fan with horizontal airflow reduces the need for tray rotation
Best for: jerky
Prefer the alternative? See the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator section.
Pros and cons of each
Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator
Pros
- 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover
- Horizontal airflow dries every tray at nearly the same rate for consistent batches
- Stainless steel trays clean up easily after resinous herbs like rosemary
- Largest drying area on this list for a full end-of-season herb harvest
Cons
- 105°F floor is higher than the NESCO, COSORI, and Presto, less ideal for the most delicate herbs
- Highest price on this list, more than most home herb growers need
- Large footprint takes meaningful counter or storage space
COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator
Pros
- 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step
- 10-tray capacity rivals the Excalibur at a lower typical price
- Rear-mounted fan with horizontal airflow reduces the need for tray rotation
- Dedicated jerky preset removes the guesswork for a first attempt
Cons
- Newer to the category than Excalibur or NESCO, with fewer years of long-term owner data
- Trays are a slightly tighter fit than the Excalibur's for thick-cut strips
- Digital touch panel has more to go wrong long-term than a simple analog dial
Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator vs COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator: common questions
Which is better, the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator or the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator?
Choose the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator if you want 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover. Choose the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator if you'd rather have 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step. Overall we rank the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky list.
What is the difference between the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator and the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator?
The Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator stands out because 9 separate trays make it easy to dry many herb varieties at once without flavor crossover, while the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator stands out because 1°F increment control makes it easy to hold a precise 160°F for the safe-start step. The trade-offs differ too: the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator's main caveat is that 105°F floor is higher than the NESCO, COSORI, and Presto, less ideal for the most delicate herbs, and the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator's is that newer to the category than Excalibur or NESCO, with fewer years of long-term owner data.
Is the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator worth it over the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator instead if 105°F floor is higher than the NESCO, COSORI, and Presto, less ideal for the most delicate herbs is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator instead of the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator?
The COSORI Premium 10-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator suits jerky, while the Excalibur D900CDSHD 9-Tray Food Dehydrator is best for herbs.