Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with vs Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper
Both made our Best Card Scraper 2026 shortlist, at #1 and #2. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges if you want two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge. Choose the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper if you'd rather have bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers. Overall we rank the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Card Scraper 2026 list.
Winner overall: Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges
Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges vs Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 8 in Best Card Scraper 2026 | #2 of 8 in Best Card Scraper 2026 |
| Pick label | Best Overall | Best Value |
| Brand | Two Cherries (Robert Larson) | Bahco |
| Key features | German tool steel; 0.8mm thickness; Edges pre-worked at the factory | Swedish made; Correct steel; Standard rectangular |
| Biggest strength | Two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge | Bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers |
| Main trade-off | Rectangular profile only -- curved and gooseneck shapes are sold separately | Single profile -- rectangular only |
| Best for | buyers who want the best overall package | value-focused buyers who want the most for their money |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick · Best Overall
Choose the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges if…
- Two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge
- Factory-prepared edges are square and ready for burnishing out of the package
- Consistent steel qualityscraper to scraper
Best for: buyers who want the best overall package
Prefer the alternative? See the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper section.
#2 pick · Best Value
Choose the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper if…
- Bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers
- Swedish steel that takes and holds a burr at a fraction of Lie-Nielsen prices
- The correct card scraper for beginners learning to turn a burr
Best for: value-focused buyers who want the most for their money
Prefer the alternative? See the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges section.
Pros and cons of each
Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges
Pros
- Two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge
- Factory-prepared edges are square and ready for burnishing out of the package
- Consistent steel qualityscraper to scraper
- A long-recommended brand among hand tool woodworking instructors
Cons
- Rectangular profile only -- curved and gooseneck shapes are sold separately
- Still requires a burnisher and correct technique
Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper
Pros
- Bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers
- Swedish steel that takes and holds a burr at a fraction of Lie-Nielsen prices
- The correct card scraper for beginners learning to turn a burr
- Widely available at woodworking retailers
Cons
- Single profile -- rectangular only
- Less consistent steel grade than Lie-Nielsen across individual scrapers
Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges vs Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper: common questions
Which is better, the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges or the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper?
Choose the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges if you want two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge. Choose the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper if you'd rather have bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers. Overall we rank the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Card Scraper 2026 list.
What is the difference between the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges and the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper?
The Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges stands out because two Cherries German steel is made from the correct tool steel grade that takes and holds a burr edge, while the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper stands out because bahco 474 is the most frequently recommended value card scraper by hand tool woodworkers. The trade-offs differ too: the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges's main caveat is that rectangular profile only -- curved and gooseneck shapes are sold separately, and the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper's is that single profile -- rectangular only.
Is the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges worth it over the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper instead if rectangular profile only -- curved and gooseneck shapes are sold separately is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper instead of the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges?
The Bahco 474-125-0.60 5-Inch Cabinet Scraper suits value-focused buyers who want the most for their money, while the Two Cherries 520-5750 Scraper with Prepared Edges is best for buyers who want the best overall package.