Skip to content
BuyOnceRight: buy once, buy right
NordicTrack Select-a-Weight · Review

NordicTrack Select-a-Weight Review

An honest, research-based look at the NordicTrack Select-a-Weight: what it does well, where it falls short, and who should actually buy it.

NordicTrack Select-a-Weight

NordicTrack Select-a-Weight

Check price on Amazon

Sponsored link · price confirmed on Amazon

On this page

Our verdict

The NordicTrack Select-a-Weight is a solid option in its class with clear strengths and a few honest tradeoffs. It suits buyers whose priorities match its strengths above; if your needs differ, the alternatives below are worth a look.

An honest, research-based look at the NordicTrack Select-a-Weight: what it does well, where it falls short, and who should actually buy it.

Fit check

Who should buy it?

A good fit if you…

  • The NordicTrack Select-a-Weight is right if: you want fine increments at the lower end of the range, you're already using iFIT or NordicTrack equipment, or you
  • Consider alternatives if: you want the longest track record and largest parts ecosystem (Bowflex), or you want a growth path beyond 55 lb per hand without buyin

Look elsewhere if you…

  • Buyers who need a different feature set, check the alternatives below.

What You Are Buying

The Select-a-Weight is a dial-adjustable dumbbell built from steel internals inside a hardened plastic shell, topping out at 55 lb per hand across 15 possible weight combinations.

It's sold as a single dumbbell or a pair bundle, and often bundled with a stand or an iFIT trial membership depending on the listing.

Performance

Weight change speed: Comparable to Bowflex's dial, roughly 3 to 4 seconds per dumbbell once seated correctly in the tray.

Increment granularity: 2.5 lb steps at the lower settings give finer control for lighter accessory work, stepping up to 5 and 10 lb increments toward the top of the range, which is a reasonable tradeoff since larger jumps matter less at higher absolute weight.

Build feel: Solid for the price tier, though the plastic shell is a step down in perceived long-term durability from PowerBlock's steel-block construction, based on owner reports over multiple years of use.

iFIT integration: Functions as advertised for guided strength sessions when a subscription is active.

What It Does Well

The 55 lb ceiling and fine low-end increments make this one of the more capable mid-tier options for lifters who want more range than Core Home Fitness's 50 lb without stepping up to PowerBlock's expansion-kit pricing.

For anyone already using NordicTrack cardio machines or an iFIT membership, the connected-workout layer is a genuine convenience rather than a gimmick, extending the same ecosystem into strength training.

What Falls Short

55 lb per hand, while competitive, still trails the practical long-term ceiling available through PowerBlock's staged expansion, so advanced lifters may outgrow it sooner.

The plastic shell doesn't feel as durable as steel-block designs over years of heavy use, based on consistent owner reports of cosmetic wear, though functional failures remain uncommon under normal home use.

Who Should Buy It

The NordicTrack Select-a-Weight is right if: you want fine increments at the lower end of the range, you're already using iFIT or NordicTrack equipment, or you want a dial mechanism with a slightly higher ceiling than Core Home Fitness.

Consider alternatives if: you want the longest track record and largest parts ecosystem (Bowflex), or you want a growth path beyond 55 lb per hand without buying a new set (PowerBlock Elite EXP).

See Also

NordicTrack Select-a-Weight vs Core Home Fitness, head-to-head comparison Adjustable Dumbbell Dial Getting Stuck

NordicTrack Select-a-Weight

Check current price, availability and owner reviews.

Check price on Amazon
Cross-shop

Worth comparing

Answers

Frequently asked questions

What weight range and increments does the NordicTrack Select-a-Weight cover?

Up to 55 lb per hand, adjustable in 2.5, 5, and 10 lb increments depending on the setting, with 15 possible weight combinations per dumbbell. The available increment sizes are finer at the lower end of the range and larger at the top, which is common across the category but worth checking against your specific accessory-lift needs.

Do I need an iFIT subscription to use these dumbbells?

The dumbbells function fully as standalone adjustable weights without any subscription. iFIT is an optional paid connected-training platform that layers guided strength programming on top, and some bundles include a trial period, but the dial-and-plate mechanism itself doesn't require it.

How does the dial mechanism compare to Bowflex's?

Similar in concept and speed, a single dial turn to a marked setting, seated in the included tray. Bowflex has a larger install base and a longer track record, while NordicTrack's finer low-end increments and iFIT integration are its main points of differentiation for buyers already invested in NordicTrack's connected-fitness ecosystem.

Is the hardened plastic shell durable compared to steel-block designs?

It holds up well under normal home use, but owner reports generally describe the plastic shell showing cosmetic wear (scuffs, minor surface marks) somewhat sooner than steel-block designs like PowerBlock. This is a cosmetic and long-term durability tradeoff rather than a functional one under typical use.

Keep researching

Related guides & comparisons