MIMidWest
MidWest iCrate vs Carlson Pet Products
MidWest iCrate vs Carlson Pet Products: we break down the real differences, strengths, tradeoffs, and which one fits your situation.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 3 min read
CPCarlson Pet
On this page
Quick verdict
Both are credible options, the right choice depends on which strengths matter more to you. If still torn, the buying guide linked below walks through the decision step by step.
The details
Head-to-head
The differences that actually change the buying decision.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| The Short Answer | Buy the MidWest iCrate if your dog is calm, weighs under 70 lbs, and you want the most, lowest-cost option in the category. | Buy the Carlson Pet Products crate if your dog weighs closer to 90 lbs, paws or noses at latches, or you want more structural margin before considering a specialty heavy-duty crate. |
| Where They Match | Divider panel: Both include one, letting either crate serve a puppy through adult sizing. | Tray design: Both use a removable leak-proof plastic tray that slides out for cleaning. |
| Where the Carlson Wins | Latch security: The multi-point system closes the gap a single slide-bolt leaves for a determined dog. | Wire gauge: Noticeably thicker, holds its shape better under a large dog's sustained weight or pressure. |
| Where the MidWest Wins | Weight and portability: Lighter overall, easier to move between rooms or load into a car. | Track record: Over 34,000 ratings versus roughly 7,800, giving buyers more long-term data points. |
| Who Should Buy Each | MidWest iCrate: calm dog under 70 lbs, budget-conscious, wants the most-reviewed option in the category. | Carlson Pet Products: large dog approaching 90 lbs, dog that tests latches, wants more structural margin before considering specialty heavy-duty crates. |
| See Also | MidWest iCrate Review, full review Carlson Pet Products Review, full review Best Dog Crates for Large Breeds, full category | See full breakdown below. |
| Frequently Asked Questions | Carlson Pet Products Dog Crate Review: Sturdier Latches for Large DogsDog Crates · Review Go Pet Club Heavy Duty Crate Review: The Sturdiest Wire Crate WeDog Crates · Review Best Dog Crates for Large | See full breakdown below. |
Decide
Which should you buy?
Choose the MidWest iCrate if…
- Buy the MidWest iCrate if your dog is calm, weighs under 70 lbs, and you want the most, lowest-cost option in the category.
- MidWest iCrate: calm dog under 70 lbs, budget-conscious, wants the most-reviewed option in the category.
- MidWest iCrate Review, full review
Choose the Carlson Pet Products if…
- Buy the Carlson Pet Products crate if your dog weighs closer to 90 lbs, paws or noses at latches, or you want more structural margin before considering a specia
- Carlson Pet Products: large dog approaching 90 lbs, dog that tests latches, wants more structural margin before considering specialty heavy-duty crates.
- Carlson Pet Products Review, full review
The Short Answer
Buy the MidWest iCrate if your dog is calm, weighs under 70 lbs, and you want the most, lowest-cost option in the category.
Buy the Carlson Pet Products crate if your dog weighs closer to 90 lbs, paws or noses at latches, or you want more structural margin before considering a specialty heavy-duty crate.
Where They Match
Divider panel: Both include one, letting either crate serve a puppy through adult sizing.
Tray design: Both use a removable leak-proof plastic tray that slides out for cleaning.
Fold-flat storage: Both fold down for storage or transport without tools.
Where the Carlson Wins
Latch security: The multi-point system closes the gap a single slide-bolt leaves for a determined dog.
Wire gauge: Noticeably thicker, holds its shape better under a large dog's sustained weight or pressure.
Weight rating: 95 lbs versus 70 lbs gives real margin for large and giant breeds.
Where the MidWest Wins
Weight and portability: Lighter overall, easier to move between rooms or load into a car.
Track record: Over 34,000 ratings versus roughly 7,800, giving buyers more long-term data points.
Who Should Buy Each
MidWest iCrate: calm dog under 70 lbs, budget-conscious, wants the most-reviewed option in the category.
Carlson Pet Products: large dog approaching 90 lbs, dog that tests latches, wants more structural margin before considering specialty heavy-duty crates.
Carlson Pet Products on Amazon
See Also
MidWest iCrate Review, full review Carlson Pet Products Review, full review Best Dog Crates for Large Breeds, full category
Frequently Asked Questions
Carlson Pet Products Dog Crate Review: Sturdier Latches for Large DogsDog Crates · Review Go Pet Club Heavy Duty Crate Review: The Sturdiest Wire Crate WeDog Crates · Review Best Dog Crates for Large Breeds: Top Picks for Big DogsDog Crates · List Our editorial team researches and writes every review independently.
Answers
Frequently asked questions
Is the Carlson crate meaningfully sturdier than the MidWest iCrate?
Yes, in two specific ways: wire gauge and latch design. The Carlson's wire holds its shape better under sustained pressure from a large or restless dog, and its multi-point latch system is harder for a dog to force open than the MidWest's single slide-bolt. For a calm dog, neither difference shows up in daily use.
Which is better for a puppy that will grow into a large breed?
Both include a divider panel and work on the same grow-with-your-dog principle. If the projected adult weight is under 70 lbs, the MidWest's 36-inch size is sufficient and cheaper. For a projected giant breed adult over 90 lbs, the Carlson's 42-inch size and higher weight rating give more room to grow into.
Is the price difference between these two crates worth it?
For a large or anxious dog that pushes harder against its crate, the Carlson's sturdier latches and wire gauge are worth the premium.
Which crate is easier to move around the house?
The MidWest, clearly. Its lighter overall build and smaller footprint make it easier to reposition between rooms. The Carlson's heavier wire gauge, which is its main advantage in sturdiness, also makes it noticeably heavier to carry.
Keep researching
Related guides & reviews
- Best picksBest Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs: Reduce Stress and Prevent EscapesThe best dog crates for anxious dogs ranked by escape resistance, latch security, and visual enclosure, covering heavy-duty wire crates for Read
- Best picksBest Dog Crates for Apartments: Compact Picks That Don't Eat Your Floor SpaceThe best dog crates for apartments ranked by footprint, fold-flat storage, and noise, covering compact wire crates that fit small living rooRead
- Best picksBest Dog Crates for Crate Training Puppies: Grow-With-Your-Dog PicksThe best dog crates for crate training puppies ranked by divider panel quality, price, and ease of cleaning, covering the standard puppy-to-Read
- Best picksBest Dog Crates for Large Breeds: Top Picks for Big DogsThe best dog crates for large breeds ranked by wire gauge, weight capacity, door configuration, and durability, covering budget wire crates Read
- Best picksBest Dog Crates Under $150: Heavy-Duty Options Without the Premium PriceRead
- Best picksBest Dog Crates Under $80: Budget Picks That Don't Cut Corners on SafetyRead