LDLush Decor
Lush Decor vs Eclipse Palisade
Lush Decor vs Eclipse Palisade: we break down the real differences, strengths, tradeoffs, and which one fits your situation.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 3 min read
EPEclipse Palisade
On this page
Quick verdict
Both are credible options, the right choice depends on which strengths matter more to you. If still torn, the buying guide linked below walks through the decision step by step.
The details
Head-to-head
The differences that actually change the buying decision.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| The Short Answer | Buy the Eclipse Palisade if the highest possible light blocking is the top priority, regardless of color choice, and per-panel pricing is acceptable. | Buy the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet pair if total cost for a full window matters more, and a dark colorway is an acceptable choice for maximum performance. |
| Where They Match | Both include genuine insulation against heat transfer, not just light blocking, and both are machine washable on a cold cycle. | Both come in four length options, making it straightforward to match either line to a specific window and ceiling height. |
| Where Lush Decor Wins | Total cost for a full window. | As a matched pair, it typically costs less overall than two Eclipse panels. |
| Where Eclipse Wins | Consistent, category-leading blocking. | The Palisade blocks 98%+ of light in every color, where Lush Decor's rate varies more by colorway. |
| Who Should Buy Each | Lush Decor Insulated Grommet: buyers prioritizing total cost for a full window and a softer fabric feel, especially in a dark colorway. | Eclipse Palisade: buyers prioritizing the single highest light-blocking rate available, regardless of color choice. |
| See Also | Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms | See full breakdown below. |
| Frequently Asked Questions | Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Review: The Category BenchmarkBlackout Curtains · Review Exclusive Home Gates Sateen Blackout Curtain Review: Finish Meets FunctionBlackout Curtains · Review Best Bla | See full breakdown below. |
Decide
Which should you buy?
Choose the Lush Decor if…
- Buy the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet pair if total cost for a full window matters more, and a dark colorway is an acceptable choice for maximum performance.
- Consistent, category-leading blocking. The Palisade blocks 98%+ of light in every color, where Lush Decor's rate varies more by colorway.
- Lush Decor Insulated Grommet: buyers prioritizing total cost for a full window and a softer fabric feel, especially in a dark colorway.
Choose the Eclipse Palisade if…
- Buy the Eclipse Palisade if the highest possible light blocking is the top priority, regardless of color choice, and per-panel pricing is acceptable.
- Total cost for a full window. As a matched pair, it typically costs less overall than two Eclipse panels.
- Eclipse Palisade: buyers prioritizing the single highest light-blocking rate available, regardless of color choice.
The Short Answer
Buy the Eclipse Palisade if the highest possible light blocking is the top priority, regardless of color choice, and per-panel pricing is acceptable.
Buy the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet pair if total cost for a full window matters more, and a dark colorway is an acceptable choice for maximum performance.
Where They Match
Both include genuine insulation against heat transfer, not just light blocking, and both are machine washable on a cold cycle.
Both come in four length options, making it straightforward to match either line to a specific window and ceiling height.
Where Lush Decor Wins
Total cost for a full window.
As a matched pair, it typically costs less overall than two Eclipse panels.
The microfiber fabric feels less stiff and hangs more naturally than the laminated Palisade.
Where Eclipse Wins
Consistent, category-leading blocking.
The Palisade blocks 98%+ of light in every color, where Lush Decor's rate varies more by colorway.
Heat insulation in intense direct sun.
Who Should Buy Each
Lush Decor Insulated Grommet: buyers prioritizing total cost for a full window and a softer fabric feel, especially in a dark colorway.
Eclipse Palisade: buyers prioritizing the single highest light-blocking rate available, regardless of color choice.
Eclipse Palisade on Amazon
See Also
Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms
Frequently Asked Questions
Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Review: The Category BenchmarkBlackout Curtains · Review Exclusive Home Gates Sateen Blackout Curtain Review: Finish Meets FunctionBlackout Curtains · Review Best Blackout Curtains for Shift Workers: Sleep in Daylight HoursBlackout Curtains · List Our editorial team researches and writes every review independently.
Answers
Frequently asked questions
Which blocks more light, Lush Decor or Eclipse Palisade?
The Eclipse Palisade, consistently, thanks to its laminated Thermaback backing, which blocks 98% to 99.9% of light regardless of color. Lush Decor's dark colorways come close, in the 95% to 99% range, but its lighter colors drop to 90% to 95%, a gap the Palisade does not show across its color range.
Which is the better overall value?
For buyers who only need a single panel, or who prioritize the highest possible blocking rate over total cost, the Palisade is the stronger pick.
Does the Lush Decor pair feel different to the touch than the Eclipse panel?
The Lush Decor microfiber fabric has a softer, less stiff hand-feel and drapes more naturally, while the Eclipse Palisade's laminated backing makes it noticeably stiffer and heavier. Some buyers prefer the softer drape; others associate the stiffer feel with more complete blackout performance.
Which is better for a nursery?
Either works well, but the choice often comes down to color needs. Lush Decor offers a range of neutral and pastel tones suited to a nursery, while the Eclipse Palisade's color range skews slightly more toward standard bedroom and living room tones. For the absolute darkest possible nursery, the Palisade's consistent blocking across colors gives it a slight edge.
More comparisons
Keep researching
Related guides & reviews
- ReviewEclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Review: The Category BenchmarkThe Eclipse Palisade uses Thermaback triple-weave technology to block 98% to 99.9% of light, the highestrate in this category.Read
- ReviewExclusive Home Gates Sateen Blackout Curtain Review: Finish Meets FunctionThe Exclusive Home Curtains Gates Sateen pairs a polished sateen twill weave with Light Block and Thermax thermal lining.Read
- ReviewLush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Review: The Mid-Range PairThe Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain ships as a matched pair with a built-in microfiber insulation layer, no separate liner reqRead
- ReviewSun Zero Easton Blackout Curtain Review: The Budget StandardThe Sun Zero Easton is the most-rated budget blackout curtain on Amazon, with over 48,000 ratings. Full review with fit and performance noteRead
- Buying guideBlackout Curtains Buying Guide: Backing Types, Sizing, and CareA complete buying guide to blackout curtains covering backing and construction types, how to size panels correctly, thermal and noise benefiRead