Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered vs Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain
Both made our Best Blackout Curtains for Nurseries shortlist, at #1 and #2. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair if you want sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom. Choose the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining if you'd rather have sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install. Overall we rank the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Blackout Curtains for Nurseries list.
Winner overall: Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair
Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair vs Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 4 in Best Blackout Curtains for Nurseries | #2 of 4 in Best Blackout Curtains for Nurseries |
| Pick label | ||
| Brand | Exclusive Home Curtains | Lush Decor |
| Key features | 52 x 63 inch pair, hidden tab/rod pocket top; Layered sheer overlay over a solid blackout lining; Softer, more decorative look than a solid blackout panel | 38 x 84 inch pair; Sheer face fabric with insulated blackout lining sewn in; Grommet top |
| Biggest strength | Sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom | Sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install |
| Main trade-off | Layered construction blocks slightly less light than a solid single-layer blackout panel | Lighter colorways in this line block less light than a dedicated solid blackout panel |
| Best for | nurseries | nurseries |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick
Choose the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair if…
- Sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom
- Blackout lining still blocks most light once fully closed
- No cords, hangs from a rod pocket or hidden tabs
Best for: nurseries
Prefer the alternative? See the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining section.
#2 pick
Choose the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining if…
- Sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install
- 38-inch width suits a narrower nursery window without excess bulk
- Grommet top glides quietly, useful for not waking a light sleeper while adjusting
Best for: nurseries
Prefer the alternative? See the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair section.
Pros and cons of each
Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair
Pros
- Sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom
- Blackout lining still blocks most light once fully closed
- No cords, hangs from a rod pocket or hidden tabs
Cons
- Layered construction blocks slightly less light than a solid single-layer blackout panel
- 63-inch length is short for taller nursery windows
Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining
Pros
- Sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install
- 38-inch width suits a narrower nursery window without excess bulk
- Grommet top glides quietly, useful for not waking a light sleeper while adjusting
Cons
- Lighter colorways in this line block less light than a dedicated solid blackout panel
- Smaller ratings base than the more established nursery blackout brands
Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair vs Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining: common questions
Which is better, the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair or the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining?
Choose the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair if you want sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom. Choose the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining if you'd rather have sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install. Overall we rank the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Blackout Curtains for Nurseries list.
What is the difference between the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair and the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining?
The Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair stands out because sheer overlay softens the look of the room during the day, useful for a nursery that doubles as a playroom, while the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining stands out because sewn-in lining means no separate blackout liner to buy or install. The trade-offs differ too: the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair's main caveat is that layered construction blocks slightly less light than a solid single-layer blackout panel, and the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining's is that lighter colorways in this line block less light than a dedicated solid blackout panel.
Is the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair worth it over the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining instead if layered construction blocks slightly less light than a solid single-layer blackout panel is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining instead of the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair?
The Lush Decor Sheer Grommet Curtain with Insulated Blackout Lining suits nurseries, while the Exclusive Home Curtains Catarina Layered Blackout and Sheer Curtain Panel Pair is best for nurseries.