Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel vs Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout
Both made our Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms shortlist, at #1 and #2. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel if you want thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself. Choose the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair if you'd rather have sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap. Overall we rank the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms list.
Winner overall: Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel
Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel vs Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 4 in Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms | #2 of 4 in Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms |
| Pick label | Best overall | |
| Brand | Eclipse | Lush Decor |
| Key features | 52 x 84 inch single panel, grommet top; Thermaback triple-weave blackout backing; Blocks 98% to 99.9% of light | 52 x 84 inch pair, 2 panels; Microfiber fabric with built-in insulation, no separate liner needed; 1.65 inch metal grommets |
| Biggest strength | Thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself | Sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap |
| Main trade-off | Sold as a single panel, so covering a standard window with two panels costs double the sticker price | Lighter colorways block noticeably less light than the darker options |
| Best for | shift workers | shift workers |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick · Best overall
Choose the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel if…
- Thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself
- Sold per panel so a wide window can be covered exactly without buying an oversized pair
- Noticeably dims a bedroom even against strong midday sun
Best for: shift workers
Prefer the alternative? See the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair section.
#2 pick
Choose the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair if…
- Sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap
- Microfiber fabric feels softer than stiffer single-layer blackout panels
- Darker colorways block close to full light for daytime sleep
Best for: shift workers
Prefer the alternative? See the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel section.
Pros and cons of each
Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel
Pros
- Thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself
- Sold per panel so a wide window can be covered exactly without buying an oversized pair
- Noticeably dims a bedroom even against strong midday sun
Cons
- Sold as a single panel, so covering a standard window with two panels costs double the sticker price
- Stiffer hand-feel than fabric-only blackout curtains
Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair
Pros
- Sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap
- Microfiber fabric feels softer than stiffer single-layer blackout panels
- Darker colorways block close to full light for daytime sleep
Cons
- Lighter colorways block noticeably less light than the darker options
- Some buyers report a factory odor on first unboxing that airs out after a wash
Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel vs Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair: common questions
Which is better, the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel or the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair?
Choose the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel if you want thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself. Choose the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair if you'd rather have sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap. Overall we rank the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Blackout Curtains for Bright Bedrooms list.
What is the difference between the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel and the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair?
The Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel stands out because thermaback backing blocks nearly all direct light through the fabric itself, while the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair stands out because sold as a pair, so a single order covers a standard window with overlap. The trade-offs differ too: the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel's main caveat is that sold as a single panel, so covering a standard window with two panels costs double the sticker price, and the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair's is that lighter colorways block noticeably less light than the darker options.
Is the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel worth it over the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair instead if sold as a single panel, so covering a standard window with two panels costs double the sticker price is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair instead of the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel?
The Lush Decor Insulated Grommet Blackout Curtain Panel Pair suits shift workers, while the Eclipse Palisade Blackout Curtain Panel is best for shift workers.