Skip to content
BuyOnceRight: buy once, buy right
Dog Crates · Head-to-head

Carlson Pet Products Double Door vs MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door

Both made our Best Dog Crates Under $150 shortlist, at #1 and #3. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.

Quick verdict

Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if you want heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price. Choose the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate if you'd rather have fits large breeds. Overall we rank the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Dog Crates Under $150 list.

Winner overall: Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch

Side by side

Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch vs MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate compared

Every difference that matters, in one table.

Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch versus MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate
Attribute
Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch product photo
Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-InchCheck price
MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate product photo
MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog CrateCheck price
Our ranking#1 of 3 in Best Dog Crates Under $150#3 of 3 in Best Dog Crates Under $150
Pick labelShortlisted
BrandCarlson Pet ProductsMidWest
Key features42"L x 28"W x 30.5"H, rated up to 95 lbs; Front and side doors; Multi-point locking latch systemSee full details
Biggest strengthHeavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar priceFits large breeds
Main trade-offCosts more than the equivalent MidWest sizeHeavy and bulky
Best forlarge breedslarge-breed puppies and adults
Decide

Which should you buy?

Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch

#1 pick

Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if…

  • Heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price
  • Multi-point latches resist nose-nudging and paw-pawing better than single slide-bolts
  • 42-inch size fits most large breeds without upgrading to a giant crate

Best for: large breeds

Prefer the alternative? See the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate section.

Check price on AmazonFull details
MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate

#3 pick

Choose the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate if…

  • Fits large breeds
  • Double doors
  • Divider panel included

Best for: large-breed puppies and adults

Prefer the alternative? See the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch section.

Check price on AmazonFull details
The trade-offs

Pros and cons of each

Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch

Pros

  • Heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price
  • Multi-point latches resist nose-nudging and paw-pawing better than single slide-bolts
  • 42-inch size fits most large breeds without upgrading to a giant crate

Cons

  • Costs more than the equivalent MidWest size
  • Heavier to carry between rooms or load into a vehicle
  • Still a standard wire crate, not rated for extreme chewers

MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate

Pros

  • Fits large breeds
  • Double doors
  • Divider panel included
  • Folds flat

Cons

  • Heavy and bulky
  • Not for strong escape artists
  • Takes up floor space
Answers

Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch vs MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate: common questions

Which is better, the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch or the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate?

Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if you want heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price. Choose the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate if you'd rather have fits large breeds. Overall we rank the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch higher: #1 versus #3 in our Best Dog Crates Under $150 list.

What is the difference between the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch and the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate?

The Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch stands out because heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price, while the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate stands out because fits large breeds. The trade-offs differ too: the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch's main caveat is that costs more than the equivalent MidWest size, and the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate's is that heavy and bulky.

Is the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch worth it over the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate?

For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate instead if costs more than the equivalent MidWest size is a deal-breaker for you.

Who should buy the MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate instead of the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch?

The MidWest LifeStages 42-Inch Double Door Dog Crate suits large-breed puppies and adults, while the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch is best for large breeds.

Keep researching