Carlson Pet Products Double Door vs Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy
Both made our Best Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs shortlist, at #1 and #2. Here's how they differ and who each one suits.
- BuyOnceRight Research Desk
- Updated
- 4 min read
Quick verdict
Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if you want heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price. Choose the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate if you'd rather have heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup. Overall we rank the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs list.
Winner overall: Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch
Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch vs Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
| Attribute | ||
|---|---|---|
| Our ranking | #1 of 3 in Best Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs | #2 of 3 in Best Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs |
| Pick label | ||
| Brand | Carlson Pet Products | Go Pet Club |
| Key features | 42"L x 28"W x 30.5"H, rated up to 95 lbs; Front and side doors; Multi-point locking latch system | 44.25"L x 28"W x 32.5"H with wheels; Heavy-gauge stackable wire construction; Removable divider and two water bowls included |
| Biggest strength | Heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price | Heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup |
| Main trade-off | Costs more than the equivalent MidWest size | Assembly reportedly goes faster with two people |
| Best for | large breeds | large breeds |
Which should you buy?
#1 pick
Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if…
- Heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price
- Multi-point latches resist nose-nudging and paw-pawing better than single slide-bolts
- 42-inch size fits most large breeds without upgrading to a giant crate
Best for: large breeds
Prefer the alternative? See the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate section.
#2 pick
Choose the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate if…
- Heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup
- Wheels make it far easier to move than the MidWest or Carlson
- Stackable design is genuinely useful for multi-dog households or kennels
Best for: large breeds
Prefer the alternative? See the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch section.
Pros and cons of each
Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch
Pros
- Heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price
- Multi-point latches resist nose-nudging and paw-pawing better than single slide-bolts
- 42-inch size fits most large breeds without upgrading to a giant crate
Cons
- Costs more than the equivalent MidWest size
- Heavier to carry between rooms or load into a vehicle
- Still a standard wire crate, not rated for extreme chewers
Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate
Pros
- Heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup
- Wheels make it far easier to move than the MidWest or Carlson
- Stackable design is genuinely useful for multi-dog households or kennels
Cons
- Assembly reportedly goes faster with two people
- Some buyers report weld quality issues on individual units
- Largest, bulkiest footprint even when folded
Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch vs Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate: common questions
Which is better, the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch or the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate?
Choose the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch if you want heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price. Choose the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate if you'd rather have heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup. Overall we rank the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Dog Crates for Anxious Dogs list.
What is the difference between the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch and the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate?
The Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch stands out because heavier wire gauge than basic iCrate-style crates at a similar price, while the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate stands out because heaviest wire gauge of any crate in this roundup. The trade-offs differ too: the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch's main caveat is that costs more than the equivalent MidWest size, and the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate's is that assembly reportedly goes faster with two people.
Is the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch worth it over the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate instead if costs more than the equivalent MidWest size is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate instead of the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch?
The Go Pet Club 44-Inch Heavy Duty Stackable Dog Crate suits large breeds, while the Carlson Pet Products Double Door Metal Dog Crate, Large 42-Inch is best for large breeds.